Signature-based detection has been a mainstay of IT security for decades, but the unique realities of operational technology (OT) environments make it a poor return on investment for power utilities. While signatures can still provide value for commodity IT malware, they fail against insider misuse, zero-day exploits, and custom-built malware designed for grid operations. Historical evidence shows signatures rarely generalize across different utilities, and overreliance creates strategic blind spots. To effectively defend critical energy infrastructure, utilities should prioritize behavioral analytics, anomaly detection, and intelligence sharing across the community.